Caterpillar 289D vs New Holland S170: Which Is the Better Value?
The Caterpillar 289D averages $42,498 CAD at auction, compared to $13,768 for the New Holland S170. That's a $28,730 difference. Based on 197 verified Canadian auction results tracked by TrackCheck, here's the full breakdown.
The Verdict
The New Holland S170 is the better value buy for most Canadian buyers, averaging $28,730 less than the 289D.
Caterpillar 289D
CTL$42,498 CAD avg
$15,938
Low
$85,752
High
173
Sales
Avg 4,178 hours · 2014–2019 model years
Full price guide →New Holland S170
SSL$13,768 CAD avg
$3,111
Low
$25,647
High
24
Sales
Avg 2,490 hours · 1999–2006 model years
Full price guide →What are the key differences between 289D and S170?
- Price: The S170 is $28,730 cheaper on average (68% savings).
- Track Type: 289D is a compact track loader (CTL) while S170 is a wheeled skid steer (SSL). CTLs have better traction on soft ground; wheeled units are faster and cheaper to maintain.
- Usage: Used 289Ds average 4,178 hours while S170s average 2,490 hours.
Both Caterpillar and New Holland retain value well. See our depreciation guide for brand rankings.
Looking for a 289D or S170? Check current listings with Deal Scores.
Which is the better value: 289D or S170?
Choose the Caterpillar 289D if:
- You work on soft ground, mud, or uneven terrain
- You prefer Caterpillar's dealer network and parts availability
Choose the New Holland S170 if:
- You want lower upfront cost ($28,730 savings)
- You work on pavement, concrete, or hard surfaces
- You prefer New Holland's dealer network and parts availability
How do 289D and S170 prices compare by year?
| Year | Caterpillar 289D | New Holland S170 |
|---|---|---|
| 2019 | $50,672 (14) | — |
| 2018 | $50,661 (16) | — |
| 2017 | $45,097 (34) | — |
| 2016 | $44,284 (36) | — |
| 2015 | $37,230 (45) | — |
| 2014 | $36,763 (28) | — |
| 2006 | — | $16,659 (2) |
| 2004 | — | $21,573 (2) |
| 2003 | — | $5,211 (2) |
| 2002 | — | $5,040 (2) |
| 2001 | — | $19,106 (4) |
| 2000 | — | $17,814 (6) |
| 1999 | — | $16,268 (2) |
Prices in CAD. Numbers in parentheses are sample size. Lower price highlighted.
How do 289D and S170 prices compare by hours?
| Hours | Caterpillar 289D | New Holland S170 |
|---|---|---|
| 0-999 hrs | $73,797 (12) | $24,588 (2) |
| 1,000-1,999 hrs | $53,030 (4) | $16,297 (10) |
| 2,000-2,999 hrs | $54,344 (17) | $16,268 (2) |
| 3,000-3,999 hrs | $47,094 (50) | $7,848 (4) |
| 4,000+ hrs | $32,996 (86) | $10,985 (4) |
Hours matter more than age for resale value. See our hours vs age analysis.
Where can I buy a 289D or S170 in Canada?
More Comparisons
Related Guides
Get Pricing
Get a Price Quote on Caterpillar 289D
We'll send you current pricing and available units. No spam.
Get a Price Quote on New Holland S170
We'll send you current pricing and available units. No spam.